French PER: lump sum, annuity or phased withdrawals?
For years the focus was on paying in. Now it shifts to what you receive, when, and on which terms. Start with the income you need, rather than a general preference for a lump sum or an annuity.
By André Ravachol, founder of Evermore · Updated 2026-10-10 · About 3 minutes to read
Check each part of the plan
Can I always choose between a lump sum and an annuity?
No. Rights built from mandatory contributions normally pay a lifetime annuity. Other contributions can generally provide a lump sum, phased capital payments or an annuity, subject in particular to any irrevocable annuity election at opening. Ask for a breakdown by contribution origin and the applicable options, not just a total balance.
Sources: Code monétaire et financier, article L224-5 · Service Public, « Plan d’épargne retraite (PER) : PER d’entreprise obligatoire »
Does transferring old mandatory rights make them freely accessible capital?
A transfer does not change the nature of these rights. Mandatory contributions retain that classification when transferred. A specific small-annuity cash-out may be available, but the provider must confirm it. It is not a basis for promising that every former article 83 arrangement can be taken as a lump sum.
Sources: Code monétaire et financier, article L224-40
Compare what each option funds
How do an annuity and regular withdrawals differ?
A lifetime annuity converts pension rights into income paid until death on the chosen terms. Capital withdrawals, where available, allow control over the pace and leave a remaining balance. They can serve different needs.
Consider a household with €1.2m of financial wealth, including €400,000 in a PER. Pensions already cover part of regular spending; travel and gifts to children are also planned. Compare an annuity quotation with and without survivor benefits against several permitted withdrawal schedules. Show net income, flexibility and what happens to remaining capital on death.
Life assurance may complement the plan with more flexible withdrawals; mandatory PER rights retain their own rules. An unindexed annuity can lose purchasing power and withdrawn capital can run out. Assess the choice across all resources, not the PER balance alone.
How should I read a withdrawal illustration?
Using illustrative figures: €240,000 divided by €1,000 a month gives 240 months, or twenty years, ignoring returns, charges, tax and inflation. This is neither a guaranteed duration nor an actuarial comparison with an annuity. At €1,500 a month, the same division gives 160 months. The pace of spending changes what the capital can fund.
Focus on money available to spend
Why does the contribution tax history matter?
For capital withdrawals funded by tax-deducted voluntary contributions, the contribution element is subject to the income-tax scale without the 10% pension allowance. Where contributions were not deducted, that element is exempt; gains have separate treatment. Ask for a dated tax illustration distinguishing these components.
Sources: Service Public, « Plan d’épargne retraite (PER) : PER individuel »
Does spreading withdrawals always save tax?
Not necessarily. Phasing payments may change taxable income in each year, but the result depends on other income, household circumstances and applicable rules. Compare schedules over the same period, including charges. A headline tax rate is not enough to decide; do not exhaust a useful reserve solely to pursue an estimated saving.
In brief
- Available options depend on contribution types and elections already made.
- Regular withdrawals spend down savings; a lifetime annuity follows contractual terms.
- Compare after-tax amounts and what happens to provision for your family.
Frequently asked questions
Can I combine a lump sum and an annuity?
Where the rights permit a choice, a combination is possible. Compare quotations with matching survivor options and dates. Mandatory contribution rights require separate consideration.
Sources: Service Public, « Plan d’épargne retraite (PER) : PER individuel »
Who confirms the final choice?
The provider confirms the plan’s options and terms. We compare income, access to capital and protection for your partner under each policy option. Your choice draws on that summary, the applicable tax treatment and the effects of an irreversible decision.
Sources
Compare my PER withdrawal options
Your PER now needs to serve your plans. Let’s compare the options actually available, their net income and how they fit with your life assurance.
- The withdrawal options allowed by your policies compared on net amounts, connecting each choice with your budget.
- Your PER, life assurance and other income on one timeline, helping arrange withdrawals and the reserve to retain.
How we work with you
We start with your question, bring together the relevant information and prepare the decisions. For your life assurance and capitalisation policies, we compare holdings, charges and management options, then organise implementation and follow-up. Your country of residence and the insurer’s conditions determine which policies are available. We coordinate with your notary, lawyer and accountant when the project calls for several areas of expertise.