Gold and commodities: four ways to gain exposure, four different risks
You want some of your capital exposed to gold or commodities. Physical metal, traded products, mining companies and derivatives behave differently. This guide explains what each gives you, helping you choose an exposure suited to its intended role in your portfolio.
By André Ravachol, founder of Evermore · Updated 2026-10-10 · About 4 minutes to read
Four exposures that are not interchangeable
What changes when you hold physical gold?
You own the metal rather than a fund share or debt security. In return, custody, security, transaction costs and taxation on sale become part of the equation. Banque de France notes that retail buying and selling of physical gold can be carried out through banks or specialised dealers and is subject to specific tax rules.
Sources: Banque de France, “La gestion de l’or”
What are gold or commodity ETFs and ETCs?
An ETF is a listed fund that seeks to track an index. In Europe, single-commodity exposure often uses an ETC: ESMA describes ETCs as debt securities providing commodity-market exposure, sometimes backed by physical metal and sometimes by other collateral or contracts. Legal structure therefore matters.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026 · ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
Why is a mining share not gold?
Because you own a company. Its share price depends on the metal price but also on costs, debt, reserves, management, jurisdictions and the equity market. A mining company can therefore rise less than gold, fall while gold rises, or amplify its moves.
What changes with futures-based exposure?
It does not follow only the spot price. Contracts need to be replaced as they approach expiry. ESMA notes that futures-based products can experience roll effects from contango (futures above spot) or backwardation (futures below spot) as well as other tracking differences.
Sources: ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
The risks behind the word “commodities”
Which risks should you assess in a listed product?
Underlying risk, replication structure, issuer or counterparty risk where relevant, liquidity, fees, tracking difference and currency. The AMF recommends reading the KID and prospectus and notes that some ETFs and index products can carry liquidity or replication risks.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
Why can the dollar change the result for a euro investor?
Many commodities are quoted in dollars. Unless the product hedges currency exposure, euro performance depends on both the commodity move and the exchange rate. The AMF highlights currency risk for ETF exposures denominated in or linked to foreign currencies.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
What role are you actually looking for?
Does gold automatically protect against inflation or crises?
No. Its behaviour varies with the period, real rates, the dollar, financial demand and other factors. It can diversify some scenarios without guaranteeing a positive return at the exact moment when the rest of the portfolio falls.
Sources: AMF, “Placements atypiques : des investissements à considérer avec prudence”
Why is one commodity not complete diversification?
Because it adds one specific exposure. Oil is heavily driven by the energy cycle, gold by different factors, and agricultural commodities by still others. Diversifying does not simply mean adding something with a different name; it means understanding what actually drives each part of the portfolio.
Compare before choosing an exposure
Which questions should you ask before comparing two products?
First define the investment idea: exposure to the gold price, mining profits or a commodity basket. These call for different instruments. A mining share adds the company’s costs, debt and management decisions; futures-based exposure adds the effects of renewing contracts.
Within a €1m allocation, a contemplated €50,000 holding is 5%. Compare what it would change: dollar exposure, sector concentration, liquidity and its relationship with existing assets. This amount is a working assumption, not a recommended weight.
The selection note should identify the underlying exposure, legal structure, replication, charges, currency and any hedging. In a life assurance policy, also establish whether that exact instrument is eligible. The word gold on a brochure does not establish ownership of metal or protection for the rest of the portfolio in every crisis.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026 · ESMA, Q&A 1275 on Exchange Traded Commodities, 23 September 2022
Why read the KID and legal structure?
Because two products with “gold” in the name can be legally and economically very different. One may be a fund, another a debt security backed by metal, and another a synthetic exposure. The KID, prospectus and issuer documentation explain the structure and its risks.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026 · ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
In brief
- Physical gold, ETCs, index funds, mining shares and commodity indices do not create the same exposure.
- In Europe, ETCs are generally debt securities giving access to commodities; some are physically backed, while others use contracts or collateral.
- Futures-based exposures can diverge from spot because contracts must be rolled and because of the futures curve (contango or backwardation).
- None of these exposures guarantees that it will rise when equities fall or inflation accelerates: the intended role needs to be tested inside the wider allocation.
Frequently asked questions
Is a gold ETC the same as an equity ETF?
They are two different instruments: ESMA generally describes ETCs as debt instruments that provide exposure to one or more commodities, whereas a UCITS ETF is a fund. Both may trade on an exchange and look similar on a platform, but their legal structure and some risks differ.
Sources: ESMA, Q&A 1275 on Exchange Traded Commodities, 23 September 2022 · ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
Does physically backed mean zero risk?
Zero risk does not exist here either: physical backing can reduce some replication risks, but it does not remove fees, structural risk, custody of collateral, market liquidity or currency risk for a euro investor. The exact product terms still matter.
Sources: ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
Why can oil exposure differ from the spot price?
Many products use futures and regularly replace expiring contracts. If futures trade above or below spot, the cost or benefit of rolling those contracts changes the return received by the investor.
Sources: ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
Do you need physical gold to gain gold exposure?
You do not need to hold physical gold. Listed products and shares of companies linked to the sector can also create economic exposure. They simply carry different risks. Choosing a product is a separate decision from deciding whether gold exposure belongs in the wealth structure at all.
Sources: AMF, glossary “ETF (Exchange Traded Fund)” · Banque de France, “La gestion de l’or”
Sources
- Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
- Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), glossary “ETF (Exchange Traded Fund)”
- ESMA, “Final Report on the Technical Advice on the review of the UCITS Eligible Assets Directive”, June 2025
- ESMA, Q&A 1275 on Exchange Traded Commodities, 23 September 2022
- Banque de France, “La gestion de l’or”
- Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), “Placements atypiques : des investissements à considérer avec prudence”
Discuss gold or commodity exposure
You are considering gold or commodities. Let’s define the exposure you want, then examine eligible investments within your policies.
- A comparison of policy investments offering exposure to metal, producers or market instruments, including costs and constraints.
- The intended role and size assessed against existing holdings, turning your investment view into an understandable choice.
How we work with you
We start with your question, bring together the relevant information and prepare the decisions. For your life assurance and capitalisation policies, we compare holdings, charges and management options, then organise implementation and follow-up. Your country of residence and the insurer’s conditions determine which policies are available. We coordinate with your notary, lawyer and accountant when the project calls for several areas of expertise.