Evermore.

Private equity: why low reported volatility does not mean low risk

A private equity proposal shows a relatively smooth performance chart. What does that tell you about getting your capital back? This guide connects valuations, capital calls, exits and charges, helping you assess the commitment over time and its possible place alongside your other assets.

· Updated 2026-10-10 · About 4 minutes to read

Read the guideDiscuss my circumstances

A smoother chart can come from the valuation method

Why does private equity often appear less volatile?

Because its holdings do not have continuously observed market prices. The AMF notes that measured volatility of certain private-asset funds is generally lower than that of listed funds because of valuation frequency and methodology. A smoother chart can therefore reflect how value is measured as much as the underlying economic risk.

Sources: AMF, “Etude de la performance des fonds d’actifs financiers non cotés commercialisés à des clients non-professionnels”, 13 January 2025

Is a fund valuation a guaranteed sale price?

No. The AMF explains that valuations of unlisted securities rely on estimation methods, including recent transactions and comparable companies, and may not match the price ultimately received in a future sale. The published valuation is an indication, not a promised exit price.

Sources: AMF, “S’informer sur… Les fonds de capital investissement (FCPR, FCPI, FIP)”, 19 June 2023

Risk often appears when you want to exit

Why is illiquidity central to private equity?

Because the underlying companies are not traded on an organised market. The AMF notes that exits can take several months and that, for some funds, redemption before the end of the fund’s life can in practice be impossible. Locked capital therefore plays a very different role from liquid listed assets.

Sources: AMF, “Investir via un fonds de capital-investissement (FCPR, FCPI, FIP)”, 23 February 2023

Is a fund’s duration always predictable?

Contractual duration provides a framework, but liquidation can be extended when holdings are difficult to sell on acceptable terms. The AMF stresses that liquidity depends on the fund’s ability to dispose of assets, which can delay the return of capital.

Sources: AMF, “S’informer sur… Les fonds de capital investissement (FCPR, FCPI, FIP)”, 19 June 2023

Performance comparisons require more care

Why is IRR not directly comparable with a listed-market return?

Because private funds have irregular cash flows: capital calls, distributions, exits and interim valuations. IRR incorporates the timing of those flows. The AMF notes that private-asset characteristics make performance measurement and comparison more difficult, leading investors to use several metrics such as IRR, multiples and Public Market Equivalent.

Sources: AMF, “Private equity : état des lieux et vulnérabilités”, 11 September 2023

Why are past private-equity returns difficult to generalise?

Because funds differ widely by vintage, strategy, duration, capital-call structure, costs and exit conditions. The AMF’s 2025 study stresses large performance differences across legal categories and fund characteristics and reminds investors that historical performance does not guarantee future performance.

Sources: AMF, “Etude de la performance des fonds d’actifs financiers non cotés commercialisés à des clients non-professionnels”, 13 January 2025

Private equity is a wealth allocation, not a separate universe

Which risks need to be added to the allocation view?

Beyond capital-loss risk: illiquidity, valuation uncertainty, duration, sector or geographic concentration, possible leverage, refinancing risk in portfolio companies, costs and the timetable of calls or distributions. The AMF’s 2026 risk outlook specifically highlights growing issues around liquidity, valuation, leverage and interconnections in private assets.

Sources: AMF, “Cartographie 2026 des marchés et des risques”, 2026

What should be stress-tested before locking up a large share of wealth?

Test the cash-flow timetable before the performance chart. With a capital-call fund, the commitment signed and the amount already invested are different. Outstanding calls must be funded even if distributions arrive late.

Within €2m of financial wealth, suppose €120,000 has been drawn against a €300,000 commitment. Another €180,000 remains payable under the fund’s terms. Reserves must also meet personal spending; that €180,000 is not spare money for another project. Then test two years without distributions and a later exit.

For private-market exposure inside life assurance, read the policy’s own subscription, valuation and withdrawal arrangements, which can differ from direct ownership of a fund. The decision concerns economic exposure, capital tied up and resources left for living expenses, rather than a quoted IRR alone.

Sources: AMF, “Investir via un fonds de capital-investissement (FCPR, FCPI, FIP)”, 23 February 2023

In brief

  • Reported volatility in private assets can be lower because holdings are valued less frequently and through estimation methods; that does not mean the underlying economic risk is lower.
  • Private equity adds material illiquidity risk: exit depends on the fund or investor being able to sell stakes that do not trade on a continuous market.
  • Interim valuations are estimates at a point in time; the price actually received in a future sale can differ.
  • The weight of private assets needs to be read alongside other assets, liquidity needs, horizon, possible leverage and future commitments.

Frequently asked questions

Is private equity less risky than listed equities?

That cannot be concluded from lower reported volatility. The AMF stresses that volatility is an incomplete risk measure and, for private assets, that the measure is affected by valuation frequency and methodology. Capital-loss, illiquidity and valuation risks need to be assessed separately.

Sources: AMF, “Etude de la performance des fonds d’actifs financiers non cotés commercialisés à des clients non-professionnels”, 13 January 2025

Can you recover money before the end of an FCPR?

It depends on the fund rules, but the AMF warns that for many private-equity funds money is not available in the short or medium term and redemption before the end of the fund life may be impossible or highly restricted. The fund rules and key information document need to be read carefully.

Sources: AMF, “Investir via un fonds de capital-investissement (FCPR, FCPI, FIP)”, 23 February 2023

Is a quarterly NAV a market price?

Not in the same sense as a continuously quoted price. It is a valuation calculated under the fund’s methodology using available information. It estimates the value of holdings, but the price obtained in a later sale can be higher or lower.

Sources: AMF, “S’informer sur… Les fonds de capital investissement (FCPR, FCPI, FIP)”, 19 June 2023

Does private equity automatically diversify a portfolio?

The label is not enough: it can add companies or strategies that are absent from listed markets, but it can also create other concentrations and, especially, a shared dependence on illiquidity. Diversification needs to be measured across total wealth, including directly owned businesses, property and future cash needs.

Sources

Review private-market exposure in my policies

A private-market proposal has caught your attention. Let’s examine its timetable, commitments and possible role within your policies before tying up capital.

  • A review of the proposal’s capital calls, exit timing, valuations and charges.
  • Those commitments considered alongside your other illiquid assets, showing what can be tied up while leaving room for your plans.

Review private-market exposure in my policies

Together, we can see whether my support would be useful to you.

Prepare for our conversation

What to have to hand

Start with your question, timetable and the records you already have. Confidential documents can be shared later through an appropriate channel.

Three questions to ask

  1. Why does private equity often appear less volatile?
  2. Why is illiquidity central to private equity?
  3. Why is IRR not directly comparable with a listed-market return?
How we work with you

We start with your question, bring together the relevant information and prepare the decisions. For your life assurance and capitalisation policies, we compare holdings, charges and management options, then organise implementation and follow-up. Your country of residence and the insurer’s conditions determine which policies are available. We coordinate with your notary, lawyer and accountant when the project calls for several areas of expertise.