Withdrawals during a downturn: understanding sequence-of-returns risk
Your capital needs to fund regular withdrawals. If the bad years arrive early, the outcome can differ greatly even with the same average return. This guide works through the calculation and withdrawal choices, helping you understand which reserves and adjustments to consider before retirement.
By André Ravachol, founder of Evermore · Updated 2026-10-10 · About 4 minutes to read
When the order of returns starts to matter
Is average return enough to assess a withdrawal phase?
No. As long as no money enters or leaves the portfolio, changing the order of the same set of returns does not alter the final result. Once withdrawals begin, the order matters: a poor year while the portfolio is funding spending does not have the same effect as the same poor year much later.
Sources: Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021
Why can the same returns produce two different outcomes?
Each withdrawal reduces the capital available for subsequent returns. An early fall therefore makes the portfolio fund spending from an already smaller base.
A worked example starts with €1m and withdraws €50,000 at the end of each of two years. A 20% fall followed by a 25% rise leaves €750,000 after the first withdrawal and €887,500 after the second. Reverse the returns and the figures are €1.2m and €910,000. Identical returns produce a €22,500 difference. Without withdrawals, both paths finish at €1m.
The calculation excludes charges and tax. It explains why a near-term spending reserve and withdrawal rules matter alongside the target return. The practical work is to decide which assets would fund spending during a fall and how the reserve would be rebuilt, without assuming a recovery date.
Sources: Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021 · Fidelity, “RMD Strategies for Volatile Markets”, 2026
Why the first years carry so much weight
Why is a downturn early in the withdrawal phase particularly damaging?
Because the early outflows occur when the capital still has many years of spending to fund. An early loss followed by sales to meet spending reduces the capital left invested for the rest of the plan. The same shock much later is applied over a shorter remaining period of spending.
Sources: Morningstar, “What If Retirees Don’t Get the Returns They Were Hoping for?”, 27 July 2026
What happens when assets are sold during a downturn?
The assets sold are no longer present if markets recover. The issue is therefore not only the fall shown on a statement, but how much capital has to be mobilised during that fall to fund spending or a project.
Sources: Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021
What a stress test should examine
Which variables should be tested together?
At a minimum: the size and duration of a downturn, the amount and timing of withdrawals, genuinely available liquidity, concentration of exposures, how different parts of your wealth behave, and the period over which spending has to be funded. Testing one assumption in isolation creates a cleaner picture than real life usually provides.
Sources: Fidelity, “RMD Strategies for Volatile Markets”, 2026
What does measuring years of spending funded mean?
It translates capital into time: how many years of planned spending could be covered in the scenario being tested, taking account of assets that can actually be mobilised and the withdrawals required. It does not predict how long the wealth will last; it lets you compare scenarios in a unit tied directly to the life plan.
Preparing withdrawals without pretending to forecast markets
Should you try to predict the next crash?
The plan should work without having to predict the next crash. Sequence risk exists precisely because the future order of returns is unknown. A stress test asks what would happen if a difficult period arrived at the wrong time, then identifies which dependencies deserve attention before decisions have to be made under pressure.
Sources: Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021
Which decisions are best prepared before withdrawals begin?
The level of spending to fund, the amount that needs to remain readily available, which assets you would or would not accept selling during a downturn, concentration across your wealth, and other sources of income. Evermore uses these questions to read your situation and advises directly on life assurance and capitalisation contracts.
Sources: Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), “Placements : qu’est-ce qu’une diversification adéquate ?”, 19 October 2023
In brief
- With no contributions or withdrawals, changing the order of the same annual returns does not change the final value; with cash flows, it can change it materially.
- A downturn early in a withdrawal phase is harder to absorb because assets sold at depressed prices are no longer present to participate in the recovery.
- Sequence risk appears whenever fluctuating assets have to fund meaningful outflows: retirement, lifestyle spending, a property purchase or drawdowns after a business sale.
- A useful stress test connects markets, withdrawals, liquidity, concentration and spending horizon instead of looking only at an average return.
Frequently asked questions
Does sequence risk only affect retirees?
Far from it. It affects any situation in which meaningful cash flows meet fluctuating assets: retirement, regular lifestyle funding, drawdowns after a business sale, a planned property purchase or a transfer of wealth. It is simply especially visible at the start of retirement, when withdrawals become recurring.
Sources: Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021
Does holding a cash reserve eliminate sequence risk?
It can reduce the risk, but does not eliminate it. Liquidity can reduce the need for some forced sales during a downturn, but it does not address every other dependency in the wealth structure. Its appropriate size only makes sense in relation to spending, other income, time horizon and the assets held.
Sources: Fidelity, “RMD Strategies for Volatile Markets”, 2026
Does a high average return always make up for a poor start?
Not necessarily. When withdrawals are involved, a strong average return can hide a fragile path: if a meaningful part of the capital has already been consumed or sold after early losses, later positive returns apply to a smaller base.
Sources: Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021
Why examine sequence risk before a business sale or retirement?
Because these events often turn an accumulation portfolio into a funding portfolio: capital now has to produce liquidity for spending, sometimes immediately. Before that transition is when needs, horizons and dependencies can usually be inventoried most calmly.
Sources
- Morningstar, “Sequence of Returns: What It Means and How to Deal”, 9 August 2021
- Morningstar, “What If Retirees Don’t Get the Returns They Were Hoping for?”, 27 July 2026
- Fidelity, “RMD Strategies for Volatile Markets”, 2026
- Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), “Placements : qu’est-ce qu’une diversification adéquate ?”, 19 October 2023
Test my withdrawals during a downturn
Your capital needs to fund your life. Let’s examine an early downturn and compare ways of organising your accessible reserve.
- Scenarios combining market falls and withdrawals, showing which years place most pressure on capital.
- A comparison of reserves and withdrawal schedules, helping you plan the spending to keep funded in the scenarios tested.
How we work with you
We start with your question, bring together the relevant information and prepare the decisions. For your life assurance and capitalisation policies, we compare holdings, charges and management options, then organise implementation and follow-up. Your country of residence and the insurer’s conditions determine which policies are available. We coordinate with your notary, lawyer and accountant when the project calls for several areas of expertise.