Evermore.

ETFs vs active management: why it is often the wrong question

You are weighing active funds against ETFs. This guide compares what you actually buy: exposure, cost, manager discretion and a role in the portfolio. You can ask what justifies higher charges and recognise when a simpler option meets the need.

· Updated 2026-10-10 · About 4 minutes to read

Read the guideDiscuss my circumstances

First choose what you want to own

Why does active or passive come after exposure?

Because the first decision is economic: global equities, smaller companies, corporate bonds, sovereign debt, a particular sector and so on. An ETF and an active fund may target very different universes. Comparing management styles before defining the exposure means comparing vehicles before deciding on the destination.

Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026

Is an ETF always a simple exposure?

No. The AMF stresses that there is a wide variety of indices and that some ETFs are complex. Market-cap weighting, factors, themes, leverage, currency hedging or replication methods can produce very different risk profiles under the same ETF label.

Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026

Cost matters, but does not answer everything

What do ESMA data show about costs?

In its recent work, ESMA observes materially lower costs for passive equity funds and ETFs than for traditional active equity funds in the samples studied. It also stresses that costs vary by category, distribution channel and product. This is market evidence, not a rule that determines which specific investment is preferable.

Sources: ESMA, “Market report on Costs and Performance of EU Retail Investment Products 2025”, 3 March 2026 · ESMA, “Report on total costs of investing in UCITS and AIFs”, 6 November 2025

Should a more expensive fund automatically be excluded?

Not automatically. Higher cost should be identifiable and justified by the role or service expected, but price alone does not determine whether a strategy is useful. Exposure, risk, process, liquidity, benchmark and what the fund adds to the allocation after fees still need to be compared.

Sources: ESMA Investor Corner, “Cost of Investment Products”

Know what you genuinely expect from active management

What is an active manager supposed to add?

Discretion: choosing securities, weights and sometimes duration, credit, sectors or cash within the mandate. That freedom only has value when it serves an identifiable objective and the investor understands where and why the portfolio differs from its reference market.

Sources: ESMA Investor Corner, “Cost of Investment Products”

Why examine the benchmark and the manager’s real freedom?

Because a fund described as active can remain close to an index while charging higher fees. The benchmark shows the starting point; holdings, weighting differences and management constraints then show whether the portfolio is genuinely making different decisions.

Sources: ESMA Investor Corner, “Cost of Investment Products”

The right answer can differ by allocation

Can indexed and active management be combined?

Yes, when each investment has a clear job. An ETF can provide broad, transparent market exposure; an active fund may offer a particular selection process, flexibility or a different universe. Then check what the combined holdings actually contain.

For a €600,000 equity allocation within €1.5m of wealth, compare an index-only approach with an index-and-active combination. The latter must explain what changes: companies held, concentration, style, total cost and intended behaviour. Two investments buying the same large companies do not automatically justify two management layers.

Within insurance policies, Evermore examines available share classes, charges and the fit with the allocation. A useful recommendation states the fund’s role, what is expected of it and grounds for review. It goes beyond recent rankings or an abstract active-versus-passive debate.

Why should the comparison be made at portfolio level?

Because a fund can look attractive in isolation and still be unnecessary if it duplicates an exposure that is already large. Conversely, a more specialised investment can have a precise role despite higher cost. The useful unit of decision is the consolidated portfolio, not the ranking of each product on its own.

In brief

  • Active or passive does not define the exposure: an ETF depends on its index, while an active fund depends on its universe and mandate constraints.
  • ESMA data generally show a cost advantage for passive solutions, but observed performance differs across categories and periods.
  • The useful test for an active fund comes down to one question: if I pay more, what am I actually buying? In other words, what the manager’s discretion adds beyond simpler market exposure.
  • An allocation can use indexed and active investments for different jobs; coherence across the whole portfolio matters more than an ideological preference.

Frequently asked questions

Do ETFs always beat active funds?

ETFs do not outperform in every case. Results vary by market, category and period.

In its 2025 report published in March 2026, ESMA notes for example that active equity funds did worse than passive funds and ETFs in 2024, and that passive equity ETFs were among the cheapest options in the sample. In the corresponding observation, active bond funds by contrast showed better net performance at the one-year horizon. This does not mean that active management “wins” in bonds: it shows that the verdict depends on the market, the category and the period observed. These are historical results, not a rule for the future.

Sources: ESMA, “Market report on Costs and Performance of EU Retail Investment Products 2025”, 3 March 2026

Is passive management always cheaper?

It is generally cheaper in ESMA’s aggregate observations, but costs vary across products and total cost also includes wrapper, transaction and distribution layers. A passive label does not remove the need to assess the total cost.

Sources: ESMA, “Report on total costs of investing in UCITS and AIFs”, 6 November 2025

Is an active fund that stays close to its index useful?

It can be, depending on its framework, services or constraints, but the investor should understand what is being paid for. When exposures remain very close to the index, comparing costs and expected added value becomes especially important.

Sources: ESMA Investor Corner, “Cost of Investment Products”

Do you need to choose active or passive once and for all?

Revisit the choice for each part of the portfolio: it can differ by asset class, wrapper, available cost and desired role. It can also change as the allocation evolves. The useful discipline is knowing why each investment is there, not committing permanently to one camp.

Sources

Compare funds and ETFs in my policies

You do not have to take sides between active funds and ETFs. Let’s compare investments for what they contribute to your allocation and what they cost.

  • Funds and ETFs compared for the desired exposure, charges and investment discretion, putting alternatives on a comparable basis.
  • A reasoned selection within your policies, showing what extra cost buys and when an index-based option is sufficient.

Compare funds and ETFs in my policies

Together, we can see whether my support would be useful to you.

Prepare for our conversation

What to have to hand

Start with your question, timetable and the records you already have. Confidential documents can be shared later through an appropriate channel.

Three questions to ask

  1. Why does active or passive come after exposure?
  2. What do ESMA data show about costs?
  3. What is an active manager supposed to add?
How we work with you

We start with your question, bring together the relevant information and prepare the decisions. For your life assurance and capitalisation policies, we compare holdings, charges and management options, then organise implementation and follow-up. Your country of residence and the insurer’s conditions determine which policies are available. We coordinate with your notary, lawyer and accountant when the project calls for several areas of expertise.