Thematic funds: conviction or disguised concentration?
You believe in a sector and want it represented in your wealth. This guide examines what a thematic fund owns, what it costs and how it overlaps with your other investments. It helps you express that conviction with the added portfolio risk understood.
By André Ravachol, founder of Evermore · Updated 2026-10-10 · About 4 minutes to read
A theme is not an asset class
Why can an attractive theme remain highly concentrated?
Because a theme deliberately selects a narrower universe than a broad market: a sector, technology, resource or demographic trend. The AMF has noted that some specialised ETF strategies focus on highly specialised or smaller companies, sometimes at the cost of lower diversification and higher concentration.
Sources: AMF, “Cartographie 2021 des marchés et des risques”, 5 July 2021, section “ETF spécialisés (sectoriels ou thématiques)”
Why can different thematic funds own the same companies?
Because the same large company can fit several stories at once: artificial intelligence, cloud, robotics, cybersecurity or energy transition. The fund name therefore does not reveal the real overlap. Top holdings and selection methodology need to be examined.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
Look behind the name
What should you examine inside the index or portfolio?
The number of holdings, weight of the ten largest positions, sectors and geographies, company size, rebalancing frequency and rules for entering or leaving the index. For an ETF, the AMF recommends looking at the securities that actually make up the reference index rather than relying on the label.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
Why does index construction matter as much as the theme?
Because two indices targeting the same theme can select different universes, cap large-company weights differently and rebalance at different intervals. Methodology therefore determines where concentration sits and what will actually drive the investment.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
Define the role of the theme in the allocation
Does a thematic fund automatically diversify a global portfolio?
No. If it already holds companies that have large weights in the global portfolio, it may simply increase those exposures. It can also add sector or regional concentration. Diversification is measured across consolidated exposures, not the number of funds.
Sources: AMF, “Placements : qu’est-ce qu’une diversification adéquate ?”, 19 October 2023
How do you distinguish conviction from duplicated exposure?
Look at what the theme changes in the existing allocation, not just how compelling its story sounds. An artificial-intelligence fund may increase exposure to companies already held through a global ETF. That is an additional conviction rather than new diversification.
Within €1m, suppose you are considering an €80,000 thematic holding. Rebuild the top ten positions before and after the purchase, then total technology and large US company exposure. If that concentration is intentional, size it accordingly. Otherwise, broader exposure or a different investment may better serve the objective.
Record why the theme is selected, its intended weight and what would prompt a review: valuations, methodology changes, excessive overlap or changed personal needs. An economically promising theme is not automatically an attractive investment at the price paid.
Sources: AMF, “Comment bien diversifier un investissement ?”, 8 July 2016
Risks that disappear behind the story
Which risks matter beyond volatility?
Concentration, liquidity of the underlying securities, currency risk, ETF replication method, tracking error and the possibility that a theme relies on smaller or highly specialised companies. The risk indicator in the key information document does not capture every dimension on its own.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
Why do fees, liquidity and currency matter too?
Because the thematic view can be right and the investment outcome still disappoint if the vehicle is costly, trades less-liquid assets or adds an unidentified currency exposure. The investment vehicle and the economic theme need to be analysed separately.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
In brief
- A theme groups companies around one economic idea; it does not necessarily diversify the risks already present in the portfolio.
- Several thematic funds do not mean several different risks: two funds with very different names can own the same large companies or depend on the same market factors.
- Reading a thematic fund means examining concentration, index methodology, top holdings, sectors, currencies, liquidity and costs.
- The useful question is not “do I believe in the theme?” but “which new risk does this theme add to what I already own?”
Frequently asked questions
Is a thematic ETF more diversified than an individual stock?
It usually owns several companies and therefore spreads company-specific risk more than a single stock. But a thematic ETF can remain heavily concentrated in a few companies, one sector or one common factor. “More holdings” does not mean “more independent risks”.
Sources: AMF, “Comment bien diversifier un investissement ?”, 8 July 2016
Does a long-term theme guarantee good returns?
There is no such guarantee: an economic trend can develop while already being highly valued in markets, or the economic benefits can accrue to companies outside the fund. A structural story guarantees neither the purchase price nor future investment performance.
Can you hold several thematic funds at once?
Yes in principle, but multiplying themes does not guarantee greater diversification. If the same large companies appear repeatedly, hidden concentration increases. The relevant assessment looks at all your holdings together.
Sources: AMF, “Placements : qu’est-ce qu’une diversification adéquate ?”, 19 October 2023
How do you compare two ETFs on the same theme?
Compare index definition, concentration, top holdings, fees, replication method, liquidity, currency risk and tracking difference. The theme is the chapter title; these details define the investment actually owned.
Sources: AMF, “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
Sources
- Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), “Ce qu’il faut savoir sur les ETF avant d’investir”, 11 June 2026
- AMF, “Comment bien diversifier un investissement ?”, 8 July 2016
- AMF, “Placements : qu’est-ce qu’une diversification adéquate ?”, 19 October 2023
- AMF, “Quelles stratégies d’investissement se cachent derrière l’ISR ?”, 2021
- AMF, “Cartographie 2021 des marchés et des risques”, 5 July 2021, section “ETF spécialisés (sectoriels ou thématiques)”
Review my thematic investments
You have an investment theme in mind. Let’s assess what it would add to your current allocation, any overlap and the investments available within your policies.
- The fund’s main holdings compared with your other investments, distinguishing a new exposure from an overlap.
- A role and risk budget discussed within the allocation, so you can express a conviction without making the whole plan depend on it.
How we work with you
We start with your question, bring together the relevant information and prepare the decisions. For your life assurance and capitalisation policies, we compare holdings, charges and management options, then organise implementation and follow-up. Your country of residence and the insurer’s conditions determine which policies are available. We coordinate with your notary, lawyer and accountant when the project calls for several areas of expertise.